CITY planners have agreed a controversial scheme to demolish lock-up garages and overhaul a Victorian house to make 20 new flats in a conservation area.

The original application for transforming Tredennyke House, in Barbourne, Worcester, was derided earlier this year by the planning committee as one of the worst designs they had seen.

The amended plan was approved at Thursday's committee meeting by seven votes to nil - with five abstentions - despite objections from five residents and lingering concerns from some councillors.

Planning officer Vicki Bilton said: "The original concept was for a three-storey block.

"Then there was an application for a smaller footprint but a more modern approach. This is a traditional style of brick and tile.

"The main issue was about the impact on the wider area and conservation area. I feel that has been addressed, particularly with regard to the traditional materials."

Councillor Paul Denham agreed. "Last time the majority didn't think it enhanced the area," he said. "My view is that this is far more in keeping."

Chairman Robert Rowden added: "I'm personally happy with the proposals for the mews flats (demolishing the garages).

"I would've preferred to see just four or six apartments in Tredennyke House but I don't see a planning reason for refusing the 10. I support it."

The brick and timber garages and nearby sheds will now be knocked down and replaced with 10 one-bedroom flats, and the main house, which currently has 15 apartments, will be reduced to 10.

There will be 20 car-parking spaces - one allocated to each flat.

Coun Barry Mackenzie-Williams had concerns over the 10 apartments in the main house - after an earlier application featured just six - and potential loss of landscaping to make room for the parking spaces.

In September, Worcester City Council planning committee unanimously opposed a bid because it failed to enhance the St George's Square Conservation Area.