WHEN plans for the transformation of Worcester's controversial Lychgate Shopping Centre were unfurled before city councillors earlier this year, we were encouraged by their response.

Councillor Ray Turner's view echoed that of many when he suggested "we can only learn from history - and I hope we do". So did we. We still do.

Today, we're able to bring you one step closer to deciding whether such hopes are to be dashed or reinforced.

The Lychgate edifice stands as a monument to the 60s, a period that infamously saw the "Rape of Worcester", the demolition of much of that old quarter of the city.

Sadly, hindsight reminds us it was a period before society learnt that heritage extended beyond major buildings.

It was also frustratingly close to the point where the post-war urge to build a brave new world ran out of concrete.

Our criticism of Lychgate has never been about the people or the businesses that have made it an important part of city life for four decades. But it has always been about the centre's appearance.

To be frank, the artist's impression released by Tops Estates hasn't set our pulses racing.

But we know many voices and many shades of opinion will colour the debate before work begins in January.

So we'll go no further now than offering this note of caution on behalf of the city as a whole.

We can't afford to spend another 40 years looking at a architectural monstrosity. There won't be a third chance. The new Lychgate must enhance the city from the word go.