PLANS to erect a triple garage in the grounds of a listed building in the Vale have been rejected by Wychavon district councillors.

The planned development, in the garden of the Monastery in Fladbury, had been recommended for approval by planning officers.

But members of the development control committee voiced concerns about the building's proposed siting. The house itself and the majority of the garden falls within a conservation area.

The proposal had provoked a number of objections from villagers and the parish council. Council chairman Bill Llewellyn, speaking at last Thursday's meeting, said: "They (the garages) are a long way from the house and anyone with any sense will not walk 75 yards to get into their car."

Other concerns raised by objectors included potential flooding problems and a possible change of use for the building in the future.

But officers felt the development's size and design, which has been reduced in height, was appropriate and alternative sitings could damage the conservation area.

Councillor Malcolm Meikle said: "I can't support the officers. It is an inappropriate siting. It would be more appropriate to site it adjacent to the highway. I don't believe where it is now in any way enhances the conservation area."

Cllr Anna Mackison said: "The Monastery has got to be the most significant building in this very special village. I appreciate the way the actual design of the building has been changed and is far more in keeping, but it should be sited closer to the road."