A MOTHER shook her baby so hard he suffered brain damage which will leave him unable to walk or talk and possibly unable to see in a case described as ‘tragic’ by a judge.
The Worcestershire mother, who was suffering from undiagnosed post-natal depression, shook the seven week-old baby for ‘a significant amount of time’, causing him extensive brain damage.
Judge Nicolas Cartwright who gave the mother a suspended prison sentence said: “This is a tragic case. You suffered an episode of severe post-natal depression after the birth of your son which went undiagnosed and untreated.
"On the day in question, when he was only seven weeks old and you were overcome with a mixture of feelings, you were led to shake him backwards and forwards for a significant amount of time. He suffered an inevitable brain injury which is permanent and grave. His life will be limited. It’s unlikely he will be able to walk or talk. The indications are that he will not be able to see.”
The baby is now in the custody of his father and the defendant’s parents.
The baby - and therefore his mother - cannot be named for legal reasons.
The mum admitted section 20 grievous bodily harm on July 6 this year - the same day that she shook the baby at her home in Kidderminster.
Robert Price, prosecuting, said the father of the boy became concerned about him after returning home from work and noticing that he appeared to be unwell. An ambulance was called and he was taken to Russells Hall Hospital, Dudley, with bruising to his left arm and back.
Mr Price said the mother initially claimed the bruising might have been caused by her thumb as she held him and the bruising to his back by the head rest in the baby bath.
A CT scan revealed extensive bleeds within numerous compartments of the brain and associated brain swelling as well as a haemorrhage in the left eye. He was taken on emergency transfer to Birmingham Children’s Hospital and medical experts said the injuries were consistent with a single episode of severe shaking.
When arrested, the mother, who was aged 26 at the time, denied being violent towards her son, claiming the injuries might have been caused when she tried to burp him and his head swung back. However, she later confessed to her mother what she had done, telling her she had suffered ‘a mental block and shook the baby’.
She asked to be re-interviewed by police, admitting what she had done. He had been ‘niggly and fidgety’ and she had experienced ‘a sudden urge to shake him.’
“She shook him backwards and forwards, away from her body. She said she did not know what had come over her,” said Mr Price.
Mr Price said the child’s prognosis was ‘not particularly promising’ in light of ‘extensive brain damage’ but he had been receiving physiotherapy since the incident and was under the care of a consultant neurologist.
Siobhan Collins, defending, said the mother had severe post-natal depression and had experienced ‘thoughts of suicide’ and ‘dark thoughts.’
“She felt she was useless and her children were better off without her. She felt unable to seek help. This was a mental block. She did not know what came over her,” said Miss Collins.
Miss Collins said the shaking was not in any way pre-meditated and that this was ‘an isolated incident’ and ‘out of character.’
“She has never offended before and, I submit, never will again. She still loves him and wants to do anything she can for him,” said Miss Collins.
Judge Cartwight sentenced the mother to 21 months in prison suspended for two years.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel